michael-dean-k/

On Monday 6/15, I'm hosting a workshop to kick off a reading group for classic essays: RSVP here.

michael-dean-k/
Michael Dean
michael-dean-k/

Architect-turned-writer, founder of Essay Architecture. Building pattern languages, software, anthologies, and community for essayists.

Essay Club ↗
Recent Essays

Didion & moralism

· 427 words

I'm 9 drafts into my Didion essay, and don't feel close to knowing what I really think. Should an essay be moralistic? I think that's the question I'm circling.

Early in its history, the essay was almost indistinguishable from moral writings; they followed a format of A (this thing happened) and B (therefore, this is how we should live). I do think there's value in each person deriving their own morals, yet also, feel there is probably value in cultures having shared standards, expectations, and a sense of what is right or good.

When I disagree with Didion, there a few ways to interpret it:

  • (A) she is bad/wrong/evil, meaning, in the pursuit of her aesthetic and her career, she has adopted ideas that I think are bad for my character, her character, or anyone's character, whether she's aware of it or not;

  • (B) she's mostly a good person, but morality is complex, and she has certain facets that diverge from my model of what "good" is (maybe from her model, I'm bad/wrong/evil);

  • (C) she's good and aligned with my beliefs, but I've misread her... the challenge is she rarely explicitly states what she stands for, and in fact, often says "nothing makes sense and everything is meaningless"

Point (C) brings up something I try to remember as I write: even if I use clever subtext to conceal something, by the end of the essay, you should know where I stand on moral/catalytic matters. Maybe that's just my preference, my attempt to articulate what I mean in precise language, so both you and I know what I think. Didion might just prefer to let readers come to our own conclusions.

But what are her conclusions? Should we celebrate incoherence? Is celebrating incoherence is immoral? I can dabble in chaos, but is all chaos and no order bad? Would she disagree with the notion that she "celebrates" chaos? Maybe she hates chaos, or she acknowledges it without wanting or promoting it, and my sense that she "celebrates" is just my interpretation because she never actually tells me what she believes. It all can get quite circular and ambiguous, which is fine, and perhaps part of the fun.

In contrast, the Essay Architecture system is straightforward in terms of objective patterns we all can see; interpreting virtue feels like dealing with gas. I don't necessarily want to make a periodic table of morals... or should I? (Actually, I have done that, but that's for me personally, and it's hard to know how any of it translates onto others).