On avoiding sales
Essay Club, despite my on-and-off efforts this year, has been hard to grow (at least, not to the degree that it needs to). "On-and-off" is the likely culprit. I've made certain concentrated efforts, and those have worked to various degrees. But it's hard for me to keep "growth" the constant top priority, because it's a functional need instead of a creative one.
I fear that for years I’ve lacked a basic sense of business self-awareness. Of course, I’ve “worked on the business,” but that almost always means obsessive work on the product. If anything in the world of business, I'm a product guy. There will be an occasional one-time post to promote something, or even rarer, a campaign, but otherwise, I’ve operated with a “find it yourself model.” I make the thing, I give it a website, I’ll mention it in an email, and then I go back to product while you find it yourself.
So, I’ve been trying some new things. In October, I launched a weekly newsletter, an opportunity to speak about my projects regularly (the club, the software, the anthology). I also realized I need better “free previews” so people can try things. This is leading to about 1 new sale per week, which is good, but still not sustainable.
Ultimately, the thing I need to do, the thing I’ve been avoiding, the thing that really has nothing to do with making the work but everything to do with selling it: sales. “Will you buy this?” I probably need to be sending 3,650 sales emails per year (10 per day), where I very openly and explicitly try to convince interested prospects to buy, and I will mostly be rejected. Even if 90% of people say no, that would be 365 new members, bringing the club to ~435 people. This is the scale that makes it feel like a proper academy, the scale required for me to sustain this full-time for many more years.
(Again, not trying to “scale” this or make it a company that’s attractive to investors or anything like that. I simply want to run a one-person essay institute as my main job, and make enough to support my family while I do so.)
It will be fascinating if this works, because it’s so simple. It’s so simple, yet it’s been so completely avoided. I’ve tried so many permutations of scheduling and prioritization, and yet all of these seemed to avoid the actual constraint of the business: no one is being asked to buy the product.